LNIB LAWS
TRESPASS LAW
MORE INFO
Lower Nicola Indian Band Legal Authority Affirmed by B.C. Provincial Court in Trespass Prosecutions
A series of recent court cases has highlighted how the Lower Nicola Indian Band (LNIB) is enforcing its land laws and protecting its community. These cases involve several non-members who lived on reserve land (LNIB land) without proper permission and were later prosecuted under the Lower Nicola Indian Band Land Code (Land Code) and Lower Nicola Indian Band Trespass Law (Trespass Law). Together, the decisions show how the LNIB responded, how the courts viewed the situation, and how community leaders, especially Lands Director Stephen Jimmie, played a key role in upholding local laws.
The LNIB governs its reserve lands under its Land Code, which acts as its own set of laws about land use. Under these rules, only Band members or people with proper authorization can live on the land. Anyone who stays without permission may be committing an offence and can be ordered to leave.
The situation began in 2023 when Barb Caldwell and Mike Pockrant moved onto reserve land and lived in a RV trailer. Although they had been invited by a Band member, they did not receive official approval. This approval is required under the Land Code, and there was also a RV Prohibition in place that prohibited living in RVs without written authorization.
In November 2023, the Chief and Council (Council) formally removed any right the two individuals might have had to stay on the land and issued written notices telling them to leave. They were given the chance to appeal. Stephen Jimmie, the Lands Director, handled much of this process. He ensured notices were delivered, explained the rules, and managed communication between the individuals and the Council.
Caldwell and Pockrant later asked for more time, explaining that they were struggling financially and needed a place to stay through the winter. Despite this request, the Council decided to move forward with enforcement. In December 2023, the Council confirmed that the individuals were in violation of the Land Code and chose to proceed with legal action.
Stephen Jimmie then took on a larger role in the legal process. Acting for the LNIB, he filed a private prosecution and provided a sworn affidavit that carefully outlined the facts and timeline. His work ensured that the case was built on clear evidence and followed proper legal procedures.
When the matter went to court in June 2025, Caldwell and Pockrant admitted they had broken the rules. The judge accepted that they had lived on the land without authorization and ordered them to pay a small fine, remove their property, stay off the reserve after a set date, and placed both on three years of probation.
A second case involved James Purdie, who was also found living on LNIB land without proper permission. Like the earlier case, he had relied on an invitation from a Band member rather than receiving official approval. The court found that he remained on the land even after being warned several times that he did not have the right to be there.
During Mr. Purdie’s sentencing in August 2025, Stephen Jimmie again played an important role. He presented a Community Impact Statement that described how this situation affected LNIB. He explained that these kinds of cases create “distress” in the community and disrupt safety. He also told the court that the Band had spent a substantial amount of money on legal costs, which meant fewer resources were available for housing, education, and health services.
The judge treated these impacts as serious. In strong terms, the court emphasized that ignoring the LNIB authority harms the community and cannot be accepted. The Honourable Judge M. Stanford stated,
“Mr. Purdie is one of many non-Band members who take advantage of the LNIB by moving onto the land and remaining there without authority. Accordingly, the sentence I impose must send a message not only to Mr. Purdie, but to the public as well, that this conduct will no longer be tolerated, and will also be prosecuted.”
The judge also noted that repeatedly ignoring the LNIB’s rules showed disrespect not only for its leadership, but for the community as a whole. Deterrence was a key goal, meaning the sentence needed to send a clear warning to others.
In the end, Mr. Purdie was fined a total of $3,500 and placed on three years of probation. He was also ordered not to return to LNIB lands and to remove any personal belongings.
Across all of these cases, the courts confirmed that the LNIB has the legal authority to manage its own lands and enforce its laws. The judges recognized that maintaining order on reserve lands is important for the safety and well-being of the community.
Stephen Jimmie’s role stands out throughout these events. As Lands Director, he was responsible for enforcing the Land Code, issuing notices, documenting the situation, initiating legal action, and submitted evidence in front of a judge at trial. He also spoke directly to the court about the impact these cases had on the community. His leadership helped ensure that the Band’s laws were not only followed but also clearly defended in court.
Taken together, these cases show both the challenges and responsibilities involved in governing First Nations land. While they reflect real hardships faced by individuals seeking housing, they also reinforce the importance of respecting the rules that protect the community.
As LNIB legal counsel noted,
“These rulings show that this path of self-governance is not only effective, but legally recognized and enforceable within Canada’s justice system. The Court’s decisions in Pockrant and Caldwell and Purdie strengthen the growing body of case law confirming that First Nation governments have the authority to prosecute offences under their own land laws. The Purdie decision is historic, the first successful private prosecution of a Land Code offence at trial, with the highest cumulative fine imposed to date. More than a legal victory, it affirms the legitimacy and enforceability of First Nation legal orders and makes clear that Land Code laws carry real force in provincial courts.”
Stephen Jimmie
Director of Lands and Housing